Insights

The Selection Process for Senior Hospitality Hires: GM, Director of Culinary and Director of Operations

A bright, empty meeting room with a long white table and black chairs.

Owners and boards rarely regret the time they spend on a selection process. They regret the shortcuts. When the role is a general manager, a director of culinary or a director of operations, the hire will shape revenue, guest experience and the leadership team for years, and most of these packages sit well into six figures. A good selection process is how you turn a long list of plausible people into one leader you can defend to owners, members and staff. This guide explains how the selection process for senior hospitality hires works in Canada, stage by stage, and, more usefully, how it should change depending on the seat you are filling.

What a selection process is (and is not)

Recruitment is about reaching people; selection is about deciding between them. A selection process is the structured set of steps that tests candidates against the real mandate: what the leader must deliver, under which owner, in which operating context. Firms describe it in different ways. Innovations Hospitality Search, a US firm, sets out six connected stages: align, define, map, approach, evaluate and close. EPV Group, a European advisory firm, frames the goal as a decision-ready candidate dossier built on "context before CV" and "mandate fit before shortlist volume". The labels differ; the logic is the same. Decide what success looks like before anyone is interviewed, then collect evidence against it.

If you are still choosing how to engage outside help (retained, contingent or in-house), start with our guide to recruitment services for employers. This article assumes the search is under way and focuses on how candidates are assessed and chosen.

The core stages for any senior hospitality hire

  1. Mandate and success measures. Why the role exists, what must change in the first 12 to 24 months, who the leader reports to and what the owner will judge. Compensation range, location, timing and confidentiality are agreed here too.
  2. Profile. Essential versus merely familiar experience: property or concept type, scale, service level, union environment, bilingual service where relevant.
  3. Market map and approach. The strongest leaders are usually employed and not applying. Dilys Search, a Canadian firm, notes that hospitality leaders who are performing well are almost never looking, which is why direct, discreet outreach matters.
  4. Structured interviews. The same core questions for every finalist, scored against the profile, by a panel that agreed the scoring in advance.
  5. Role-specific assessment. A practical exercise that mirrors the job (more on this below).
  6. Track-record and reference checks. Verified results and conversations with people who saw the candidate lead, not only the referees they choose.
  7. Offer and transition. Package, notice period, relocation and the first 90 days.

How long does this take? Published ranges vary by firm and model. Talent Inc., a Canadian search firm focused on luxury hospitality, says a shortlist of typically three to five candidates is usually presented within four to eight weeks. EPV Group limits its shortlist to one to three candidates and targets six to ten weeks for a retained search. Total time to start depends on interview availability, notice periods and relocation.

How the selection process changes by role

This is where many processes fall short. The stages above apply to every leadership hire, but the evidence you need is different for each seat.

General manager

For a GM, the selection process should test commercial judgment and owner relations as much as operations. Useful elements are a business case on the property's real numbers, a site walk with a written debrief, and references from owners or asset managers as well as from brand or management company superiors. We cover the GM scorecard, business case and deep references in detail in our guide to hotel general manager recruitment, so we will not repeat it here. For multi-property roles, add a portfolio exercise; see hotel area general manager recruitment.

Director of culinary

For a culinary leader, the deciding evidence is what they put on the plate and how they run the kitchen as a business. A strong process includes a tasting tied to the actual brief (members' dining, banquets, a restaurant concept), a costing or menu-engineering exercise, a look at how the candidate plans labour and purchasing, and references from people who worked under them, because brigade retention is one of the best predictors of success. Our article on culinary expertise explains how to assess the craft itself, and director of culinary jobs shows how these roles are structured.

Director of operations

For a director of operations, whether in a hotel or a multi-unit restaurant group, the process should test systems thinking and the ability to lead through other managers. An operations review works well: give finalists an anonymised set of results (labour, food and beverage cost, guest scores, turnover) and ask them to prioritise. Reference calls should include general managers or unit leaders who reported to the candidate. For the restaurant side, see restaurant director of operations recruitment.

Who should be in the room

Keep the decision panel small and consistent: the hiring executive or owner's representative, one peer who will work closely with the new leader, and the search partner as facilitator. For private clubs, agree in advance how the board or search committee will be involved so candidates are not interviewed by a different group at every round. A panel that changes between rounds is one of the most common reasons good finalists withdraw.

Common mistakes in senior selection

  • Skipping the mandate. Interviewing before agreeing what success looks like leads to hiring the most likeable candidate, not the right one.
  • Too many rounds. Strong candidates are employed and have options. Five or six rounds spread over months signals indecision.
  • Title-matching. A director of operations at a 600-room convention hotel and one at a 120-room boutique property are different jobs. EPV makes the same point: a leader for a stable hotel does not automatically need the same profile as one leading a critical transition.
  • Thin references. Two friendly referees chosen by the candidate are not evidence. Ask for people who saw them under pressure.
  • Pay surprises at the offer stage. Agree the range during the mandate stage and test it with the market early.

What candidates should expect

If you are a hospitality leader in a selection process, expect a structured conversation about results, not just responsibilities. Bring numbers you can stand behind, be ready for a practical exercise, and tell the search partner early about your notice period, relocation needs and compensation expectations. A well-run process should also give you a clear view of the owner, the mandate and the team you would inherit.

Frequently asked questions

How many candidates should reach the final stage?

Usually two to four. Published practice ranges from one to three (EPV Group) to three to five (Talent Inc.). The aim is a short list of genuinely qualified, interested people, not volume.

Should internal candidates go through the same selection process?

Yes. Running internal and external candidates against the same mandate, interviews and exercises is fairer to everyone and gives the owner a real comparison.

Is a practical exercise fair to employed candidates?

It is if it is short, relevant and respectful of their time. A two-hour business case or a focused tasting is reasonable at finalist stage; unpaid weeks of consulting are not.

Hero image: "Minimalist meeting room" by Breather, via Wikimedia Commons, released under CC0; cropped.

Run a clear selection process with Lecours Group

Lecours Group has recruited hospitality leaders since 1991, in Toronto and across Canada first and selectively in New York, Miami and Atlanta. Owners, management companies, restaurant groups and private clubs can find candidates with Lecours Group or contact our team to plan the selection process for a general manager, director of culinary or director of operations hire. Leaders ready for their next move can view our current openings, including a General Manager, Premium Quick Service (#10343) role in Waterloo, Ontario, on our find jobs page. More answers are on our FAQs page.

Written by the LecoursGroup executive search team. Meet our recruiters.