A golf club general manager search in Ontario is one of the most consequential decisions a club board will make. The GM runs a business with several revenue streams (dues, golf operations, food and beverage, events), manages a large seasonal workforce and reports to volunteer directors who change every few years. A strong GM can keep a club steady through several board turnovers. A poor fit can cost a club members, staff and years of momentum. This guide explains how Ontario boards can run a GM search with the rigour the role deserves. Whether the board runs the search itself or retains executive search hospitality recruiters, the same discipline applies.
Why a golf club general manager search in Ontario is unique
Ontario's club market is concentrated. The GTA, Hamilton–Niagara, Kitchener–Waterloo, London and cottage country all have established private and semi-private clubs, many of them competing for the same small pool of proven leaders. Boards typically face three challenges:
- A small, visible candidate pool. Many qualified GMs are already employed at neighbouring clubs, so approaches have to be confidential.
- Seasonality. The busy season limits when sitting GMs can interview or move. Most transitions work best between late fall and early spring.
- Governance complexity. The GM has to work with boards, committees and members whose expectations don't always line up.
In Ontario, GM searches are often handed to firms that specialize in golf. Boards can and should expect more than a list of names: a documented process, a defined candidate assessment, and advice on pay and governance.
Step 1: Align the board before you look outward
Before you approach any candidate, the board needs a shared view of the club's next five years. Is the priority a capital project, membership growth, an F&B turnaround or simply stability? Each points to a different profile. A club building a new clubhouse needs someone who has managed construction and member financing. A club with a waitlist may need an operator who can sharpen service and the member experience.
Questions to settle in committee
- Is this a GM role or a GM/COO role with authority over every department head?
- What decisions does the GM own, and which stay with the board?
- What will success look like at 12 months and at 36 months?
- Is an internal candidate being considered, and how will they be treated fairly?
Step 2: Build a profile around real competencies
The Club Management Association of Canada (CMAC) lists 11 core competencies for professional club management, as identified by the CMAA: leadership; interpersonal skills; club governance; accounting, finance and data analytics; external governmental influences; human and professional resources; membership and marketing; food and beverage; golf, sports, recreation and wellness; facilities management; and information technology. These make a useful framework for a GM scorecard because they reflect the breadth of the job.
Weight them for your club. A club with a large banquet business should look hard at food and beverage depth. A club coming out of a governance dispute should put more weight on board relations and communication.
Credentials worth noting
The Certified Club Manager (CCM) designation is a meaningful signal. According to CMAC's certification requirements, candidates must be Professional Members, earn 300 credits (including 200 education credits), complete four BMI courses including the General Manager/COO module, and meet a six-year membership requirement. Relevant professional experience can be substituted for up to three of those years. A CCM isn't required for every role, but it shows a sustained commitment to club management as a profession.
Step 3: Compensation and the offer package
In Lecours Group's placement experience, club general managers commonly carry total compensation above $100,000 a year, often with a performance bonus and benefits. Published examples show the range. The CMAA and Club Benchmarking FY2023 data put the median salary of the 50 lowest-paid US club GMs at US$130,000 and of the 50 highest-paid at US$488,402, with club revenue explaining much of the difference. In Ontario, the Ladies' Golf Club of Toronto posted its GM role at $200,000+ including base salary and benefits, and a private golf and country club in London advertised $110,000 to $140,000 (archived January 2026 posting) for a GM serving as chief operating officer. Boards should benchmark against comparable Ontario clubs of similar revenue, membership size and complexity, and expect total pay to include:
- Base salary appropriate to the club's revenue and scope
- An incentive tied to agreed financial and member-satisfaction goals
- Professional development, including CMAC conferences and BMI coursework
- Club-specific perks such as playing privileges, a vehicle allowance or housing in remote settings
A clear, written incentive plan helps retention as much as base pay does. Ambiguous bonus terms are a common reason GMs leave.
Step 4: Run a confidential, structured process
- Market mapping: Identify sitting GMs, assistant GMs and clubhouse managers in Ontario and other provinces, plus hospitality leaders from resorts and hotels who have relevant experience.
- Confidential outreach: Approach passive candidates discreetly. Many will only talk if their current board won't hear about it.
- Shortlist: Present four to six candidates with written assessments against the scorecard.
- Board interviews: Use a consistent set of questions and a scoring rubric. Hold a site tour and an informal dinner as well.
- Referencing: Speak to past presidents, department heads and, where appropriate, members.
- Offer and transition: Agree on a start date that respects the candidate's current club and its season.
The same principles apply to senior F&B roles. Our food and beverage recruiters page explains how search fees are structured.
Step 5: Plan the GM's first year
A new GM needs the board's backing. Agree on a 100-day plan, arrange meetings with each committee chair, and share financial statements, capital plans and member survey data in advance. The board should resist the temptation to manage the GM directly. The point of hiring a strong professional is to let them lead.
Common mistakes in Ontario GM searches
Hiring the last GM's opposite
Boards that are frustrated with a departing GM often overcorrect. If the last leader was too operational, they hire a pure strategist who struggles with service standards, or the reverse. Go back to the five-year priorities, not the last GM's weaknesses.
Letting the search become public too early
Ontario's club community is close-knit. If a shortlist leaks, sitting GMs will drop out to protect their current jobs. Keep candidate names inside the search committee, use non-disclosure language in correspondence, and hold interviews away from the clubhouse when that's appropriate.
Underestimating food and beverage
At many clubs, F&B is the most complex department and the one members talk about most. A GM candidate with deep golf operations experience but little exposure to banquets, kitchen labour or menu pricing will need strong support. Test this directly in interviews, and consider whether your culinary leadership is strong enough to balance it.
Skipping the member perspective
Members shouldn't run the search, but a short survey or a few focus groups before the profile is written can reveal what matters to them: service consistency, family programming, dining quality or communication. Their answers make the scorecard sharper and help the board explain its eventual choice.
Rushing the timeline
A thorough GM search usually takes several months from approval to start date, especially when the preferred candidate needs to see their current club through its season. Boards that start in early fall have the most options for a spring arrival.
Frequently asked questions
How should a board handle an interim period between GMs?
Name a clear interim leader, usually the assistant GM or controller, and tell staff and members about it promptly. Avoid letting the board president step into day-to-day operations. That blurs governance and can make the role less attractive to outside candidates.
Is it realistic to recruit a GM from outside Ontario?
Yes. Candidates from other provinces, and sometimes the US, bring fresh perspective. Budget for relocation and factor in the time a family move takes. Cross-border hires also raise work-authorization questions, so get immigration advice early.
How many board members should sit on the search committee?
Three to five is a practical range: enough to represent the board's views, but small enough to schedule interviews quickly and keep things confidential. The committee should recommend a candidate to the full board rather than run every interview with the full board.
Talk to us about your GM search
Lecours Group has supported hospitality and club leadership hiring since 1991. To start a confidential golf club GM search, review how we find candidates or contact us directly. Club professionals exploring their next move can view our open roles.
