Insights

Why Experienced Hospitality Managers Aren’t Getting Interviews in Canada

Toronto financial district and Old City Hall at night, photorealistic.

Experienced hospitality managers who are not getting interviews in Canada often assume the problem is their resume, their age or the market. Sometimes it is one of those. More often, it is a mismatch between how senior roles are actually filled and how the job search is being run. A general manager, director of operations or senior restaurant manager can send strong applications to every posting they find and still hear nothing, because many of the roles they are best suited for were never posted at all. Below, we explain why that happens and what senior managers can do about it, from the perspective of a firm that handles many of those confidential appointments.

Lecours Group's hospitality recruiters work with hotels, private clubs, restaurant groups and foodservice companies across Canada. We speak with experienced managers every week who are frustrated by silence. The patterns below are the ones we see most often.

Many senior roles are never advertised

At the manager and general manager level, much of the hiring happens quietly. An owner may need to replace a general manager who has not yet been told. A hotel may be planning an opening that is still confidential. A private club's board may not want members to learn about a leadership change from a job site. A restaurant group may simply prefer a shortlist of proven people to a flood of applications.

In each case, the employer turns to its own network or to a search firm, and the role is filled through direct approaches and referrals. If your job search consists only of responding to postings, you are competing for the visible part of the market and missing much of the rest. That is not a reflection of your ability. It is a question of where you are looking and who knows you are available.

Why strong applications go unanswered

Even when a senior role is posted, there are reasons an experienced candidate may not hear back that have little to do with merit.

  • The role was posted for visibility, not to source. Some advertisements exist while a preferred candidate is already in final conversations.
  • The volume is overwhelming. Public postings for management roles can attract far more applications than a small team can read carefully, and good resumes get lost.
  • The resume reads at the wrong level. A senior manager whose resume lists daily tasks can look like a supervisor to a quick reader.
  • The fit is unclear. If a hotel general manager applies to a private club or a restaurant group without explaining the connection, the reader may not make it for them.
  • Automated screening. Some application systems filter on titles or wording that do not match how hospitality careers are actually described.

None of these are solved by sending more applications. They are solved by changing how you are seen.

Make your resume read at the right level

A senior hospitality resume should show outcomes, not activities. Readers want to see what you were responsible for and what changed under your leadership. For each role, lead with scope: the property or concept, the size of the operation and the team, and who you reported to. Then describe results in plain language, such as a turnaround, an opening, improved guest feedback, better retention, stronger inspection results or a successful renovation. You do not need to publish internal financial figures; describing the challenge, the action and the direction of the result is enough to start a serious conversation.

Cut what does not support the level you want. Early roles can shrink to a line. Generic phrases such as "results-driven leader" add nothing. A clear profile of two or three sentences explaining the kind of operations you lead and the problems you solve will do more than a long list of strengths.

Be findable before you need to be

Because so much senior hiring is confidential, the question is not only whether you apply, but whether the right people can find you. A few practical steps make a real difference.

  • Keep a professional profile current. Your title, current operation and a short summary should be accurate and easy to read, even if you are not openly looking.
  • Use the words employers use. Describe your role in the terms a hotel owner, club board or restaurant group would search for, such as general manager, director of food and beverage or director of operations.
  • Stay visible in the industry. Industry associations, local hospitality events and professional groups keep your name in circulation.
  • Tell a small number of trusted people. Former colleagues, suppliers and owners often hear about confidential openings first.

If you are focused on Ontario, our overview of restaurant manager jobs in Ontario covers the provincial market in more detail.

How a search firm engages candidates

When a search firm is retained to fill a senior hospitality role, the work usually starts with a brief from the employer, then a map of the people who could do the job. Many of those people are not looking. They are approached directly, often by phone or a private message, and invited to a confidential conversation. Candidates who are already known to the firm, and whose experience is clearly understood, are easier to put forward quickly.

A good first conversation is two-way. The consultant will ask about your experience, your reasons for considering a move and what would make an opportunity worth your time. You should ask about the employer, the reporting line, the challenges in the role and how the process will run. A credible firm will explain how your information is handled and will not share your resume without your agreement.

Be careful with approaches that do not feel right. To learn how to tell a genuine approach from a scam, see our guide on fake recruiter warning signs in Canada.

How to stay on a search firm's radar

Being known to a firm is useful, but staying top of mind takes a little effort, and it should never feel like pestering.

  • Send an updated resume when something changes, such as a promotion, an opening you led or a move to a new property.
  • Be clear about what you want. Tell the consultant the type of operation, the region and the level that would interest you, and what would not.
  • Respond, even when the answer is no. A quick, polite reply to an approach that is not right builds goodwill for the next one.
  • Refer others. Recommending a strong colleague for a role that does not fit you is remembered.
  • Keep your references ready. Senior appointments move quickly at the end, and prepared references help.

Frequently asked questions

Should I stop applying to posted roles?

No. Posted roles are still worth pursuing when they are a genuine fit. The point is to add confidential channels alongside them, rather than relying on applications alone.

Will my current employer find out?

A professional search firm treats candidate conversations as confidential and should not share your details without your permission. Ask how your information will be used before you send it.

Is it worth contacting a search firm before I am ready to move?

Often, yes. An early conversation helps a firm understand your experience, so it can think of you when the right confidential role appears.

What a hospitality-rooted firm adds

Lecours Group has spent years appointing managers and general managers across Canadian hospitality, often for roles that were never advertised. We understand how owners, boards and operators judge senior candidates, and we can tell you honestly how your experience is likely to be read. Review the hospitality clients we've placed for to see the organizations that trust us with these appointments.

Start a confidential conversation

We are currently recruiting a Restaurant Manager (#10836) for a fine dining restaurant in Toronto. You can see that role and our other current openings, and send us your resume in confidence. If you are an employer planning a senior appointment, tell us about the role through our find candidates page.

Our team speaks with experienced hospitality leaders across the country every week. Meet our recruiters and see who would be the right person to talk to.

Photo: “Toronto August 2017 04” by Arild VĂ¥gen, via Wikimedia Commons, licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0; resized. Illustrative Toronto skyline only; no endorsement or client relationship implied.