Insights

Job Hopping in Hospitality: How a Search Firm Reads Short Tenures

Peninsula Lake in Muskoka, Ontario in winter, photorealistic.

Job hopping in hospitality is one of the most misunderstood issues in senior hiring. An owner or board looks at a chef's or manager's career, sees two or three short stints in a row, and worries that the candidate will not stay. Sometimes that worry is justified. Often it is not. When Lecours Group's hospitality recruiters review a senior career in Canada, short tenures are a question to answer, not a verdict. Here is how we read them, what usually explains them, and how we check the story before we put a candidate forward.

Why short tenures are common in Canadian hospitality

Hospitality careers have always included movement. Openings, closures, renovations, seasonal operations and changes of ownership are part of the industry. Since 2020, that movement has been sharper than usual. Many Canadian restaurants, hotels and clubs closed, paused, reopened under new owners or changed concept entirely. Leaders who did nothing wrong found themselves changing roles more often than they ever had before.

That context matters. A run of short stints between 2020 and the recovery that followed can mean something very different from the same pattern in a stable period. We always read tenure against the history of the business, not just the dates on the page.

How we read two or three short stints

When we see a cluster of short tenures, we ask a few simple questions in order.

  • What happened to the business? Did it close, sell, change concept or lose its owner? If the business changed underneath the candidate, the move often explains itself.
  • Who initiated the move? Was the candidate recruited away, let go in a restructuring, or did they leave because the role was not what was promised?
  • Was the role temporary by design? Seasonal resorts, opening teams, interim leadership and fixed-term contracts are meant to end.
  • Is there a pattern behind the pattern? Three short roles at three businesses that each failed tell a different story from three short roles at three healthy businesses.
  • What happened before and after? A long, successful tenure on either side of a difficult period often carries more weight than the short stints themselves.

What concerns us is not short tenure on its own. It is unexplained short tenure, especially when the reasons keep changing or always place the blame elsewhere.

Closures and ownership changes

These are the most common explanations we hear, and usually the easiest to confirm. A restaurant that closed, a hotel that changed flags or management companies, a club that restructured after a new board took over: all of these can end a role through no fault of the leader.

A strong candidate can explain what they did during the change. Did they keep the team together through a sale? Did they help close a business responsibly? Did they stay to stabilize operations under a new owner before moving on? Those details often reveal more about leadership than a long, uneventful tenure would.

Seasonal and club contracts

Ontario's resort, cottage-country and golf club calendars create genuinely seasonal senior roles. Ski areas, lodges and summer resorts in other provinces do the same. Some chefs and managers deliberately build careers around these seasons, moving between a summer property and a winter one, or working a defined contract at a club before returning to a year-round role.

We read these careers differently. The question is not why each role ended, but whether the candidate was invited back, promoted from season to season or trusted with more each year. Repeat engagements are a strong signal of performance.

Openings, turnarounds and interim roles

Some senior leaders are specialists in the early or difficult stages of a business. Opening chefs, turnaround general managers and interim directors are brought in for a defined purpose, and they often move on once it is achieved. A run of short tenures in these roles can be the sign of a highly valued specialist rather than a restless one.

What we look for is whether the objective was met. Did the opening launch on time? Did the turnaround improve the business? Would the owner bring that person back for the next project?

Patterns that do raise questions

Not every short tenure has an innocent explanation, and employers rely on us to notice the difference. We look more closely when a candidate leaves several healthy, stable businesses quickly, when moves follow a pattern of conflict with owners or teams, or when the same reason is given for every departure without any supporting detail. None of these automatically rules a candidate out, but each one means we need a fuller conversation before we recommend them.

How each move should be framed

From our side of the desk, the most helpful explanations are short, factual and consistent. A candidate does not need to defend every move at length. They need to give a clear reason, the context, and what they achieved while they were there.

For example: "The restaurant was sold, and the new owners brought in their own team. Before the sale, I rebuilt the kitchen brigade and reopened after the renovation." That kind of answer gives us what we need. What raises concern is vagueness, criticism of every former employer, or a story that changes between conversations. For guidance on how a senior chef's experience is presented on paper, see our article on the chef de cuisine resume.

How a search firm checks the story

Because short tenures are a real concern for employers, we verify the explanation before we present a candidate. The process is careful and confidential.

  • Public context. We confirm what happened to the business where we can: a closure, a sale, a rebrand or a change of operator.
  • Conversations with people who worked alongside the candidate. Former owners, general managers, board members and senior peers can usually confirm why a role ended.
  • Consistency. We compare what the candidate told us with what we hear from others. Small differences are normal. Different stories are not.
  • Timing. We check that dates line up, because overlaps or unexplained gaps are often where misunderstandings start.

We never contact a current employer without the candidate's permission. For more on how we approach this stage of a senior appointment, read our guide to reference checks for hospitality leaders.

What we tell employers

When we put forward a candidate with short tenures, we explain the context to the employer directly. An owner who understands that a chef's last two roles ended because one restaurant closed and another was sold is far more likely to look at the candidate's actual ability. We would rather address the question up front than let it quietly rule out a strong leader.

Equally, if the story does not hold up, we say so. Our credibility with employers depends on giving them an honest read.

Frequently asked questions

Do short tenures rule a candidate out?

No. Unexplained or repeated short tenures with no clear reason raise questions, but well-understood moves rarely stop a strong candidate.

Should seasonal roles be grouped together?

Often, yes. Grouping repeat seasons at the same property shows continuity and makes the career easier to read.

Will a search firm ask about every move?

For senior roles, usually. Expect to explain the reason for each change briefly and honestly.

What a hospitality-rooted firm adds

Lecours Group knows the history of the Canadian hospitality market, including the closures, sales and reopenings of recent years. That lets us read a senior career in context and represent candidates fairly to employers. Review the hospitality clients we've placed for to see the organizations that trust our judgement.

Start a confidential conversation

We are currently recruiting a Chef de Cuisine (#10877) for a prestigious private club in Toronto. You can see that role and our other current openings, and send us your resume in confidence. If you are an employer planning a senior appointment, tell us about the role through our find candidates page.

Our team has spent years placing culinary and operations leaders across Canadian hospitality. Meet our recruiters and see who would review your experience.

Photo: “Peninsula Lake, Muskoka” by Whpq, via Wikimedia Commons, licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0; resized. Illustrative Ontario cottage-country setting only; no endorsement or client relationship implied.