Recruitment services for employers range from a job posting with an agency's name on it to a fully retained, exclusive search led by a senior consultant. For a hotel owner, a private club board or a restaurant group hiring a general manager, a director of operations or a culinary director, the choice of service model matters more than the choice of logo. It decides how far the search reaches, how candidates are assessed, how long it takes, what it costs and what happens if the hire does not work out. This guide explains the main recruitment services for employers in Canadian hospitality, what each one actually delivers, and how to match the service to a six-figure leadership role.
Why the service model matters for leadership hires
Senior hospitality roles are expensive to get wrong. Current Ontario postings show the level: an upscale lifestyle hotel in downtown Toronto lists its general manager role at C$150,000 to C$170,000 a year (posting on Jobs.ca, October 10, 2026); The St. Regis Toronto lists its Director of Food and Beverage at C$144,000 to C$197,400, bonus eligible (Marriott careers); and a multi-site contract dining director role in the GTA lists C$150,000 to C$175,000 plus an annual incentive bonus (posting). At that level, a vacancy or a wrong hire affects revenue, guest scores, team retention and owner confidence for a year or more. That is why the way the search is run deserves as much attention as the job description.
The main recruitment services for employers
1. Retained search
The employer engages one firm exclusively for a defined role, usually paying the fee in stages (for example at engagement, at shortlist and at hire). In return, the firm commits a senior consultant, maps the whole market, approaches people who are not looking, runs structured interviews and referencing, and manages the offer. Retained search is the standard model for general managers, directors of operations, culinary directors and other executive committee roles, and for any confidential replacement. One US firm's published retained offer, for example, includes up to a one-year replacement guarantee (source).
2. Engaged or "contained" search
A hybrid: a smaller engagement fee secures commitment and priority, with the balance due only when the employer hires through the firm. It suits roles that are senior but not confidential, or employers who want commitment without a full retainer.
3. Contingent recruitment
No fee unless a hire is made. The firm sends résumés from its existing network, often in competition with other firms working the same role. Contingent work can be fast for unit-level management positions with a large candidate pool, but it rarely produces a full market map, and senior candidates who are happily employed are seldom approached properly.
4. In-house recruiting and postings
Many groups have talent acquisition teams that do excellent work on volume and mid-level roles. Where they struggle is reaching passive leaders at competitors, keeping a replacement confidential, and benchmarking pay for a role the company has never hired before.
What a good search actually delivers, stage by stage
- Briefing and role definition. A working session with the owner, board or senior leadership to agree on the mandate: what the new leader must fix or build in the first 12 to 24 months, who they report to, the budget they own and the culture they join.
- Pay and market benchmarking. A clear view of what comparable roles pay in Toronto, Ontario and across Canada, so the offer is credible before the first call is made.
- Market mapping and outreach. A list of target organisations (competing hotels, clubs, restaurant groups, contract dining companies) and direct approaches to the people doing the job well there.
- Assessment. Structured interviews against the mandate, case or practical exercises where relevant (a P&L review for a GM, a tasting and menu costing exercise for a culinary director), and early referencing.
- Shortlist. A small number of fully assessed candidates rather than a pile of résumés. One Canadian search firm, for example, publishes a target of 2 to 4 vetted candidates, a 10 to 14 day shortlist and 35 to 60 days to placement (source); timelines vary by role and market, and relocation or notice periods can extend them.
- Offer and onboarding. Negotiation support, counter-offer management, resignation coaching and check-ins during the first months.
What recruitment services cost
Fees for permanent placements are usually a percentage of first-year base salary. A 2026 US benchmark report on restaurant recruiting fees puts direct-hire fees for general manager and senior chef roles at 25% to 35% of first-year salary (US benchmark). Canadian terms are negotiated case by case, but the US range is a useful reference point. As an illustration only, 25% of a C$150,000 base would be C$37,500.
When comparing proposals, look past the headline percentage:
- Is the fee calculated on base salary only, or on base plus bonus?
- When is each instalment due, and what happens if the employer cancels or fills the role internally?
- How long is the guarantee, and is it a free replacement search or a partial refund?
- Who actually runs the search day to day, and how many other searches are they carrying?
- Will the firm stay away from recruiting your own leaders afterwards?
Matching the service to the role
- General manager of a hotel, club or flagship restaurant: retained. See our guides to hotel general manager recruitment and golf club general manager search in Ontario.
- Director of operations or regional leader for a restaurant group: retained or engaged. Our post on restaurant director of operations recruitment covers the profile.
- Culinary director or senior chef: retained or engaged, with a structured tasting. See how to hire a chef in Canada.
- Department heads in a hotel (finance, HR, engineering, sales): engaged or retained depending on confidentiality and market depth.
- Unit-level managers with a deep local pool: in-house recruiting or contingent support can work well.
For pay context before you brief anyone, see our pages on hotel general manager salary in Canada and private club general manager salary.
Questions to ask before you sign
- What similar leadership roles have you filled in Canada in the last two years, and can we speak to those clients?
- How will you reach candidates who are not looking?
- How do you assess leadership, financial judgment and culture fit, not just experience?
- How will you keep the search confidential if the current incumbent is still in place?
- What will we receive each week, and when should we expect a shortlist?
How Lecours Group works with employers
Lecours Group has recruited hospitality and culinary leaders since 1991, in Toronto and across Canada first and selectively in New York, Miami and Atlanta. We work with hotel owners, private clubs, restaurant groups and food companies on general manager, director and culinary leadership searches, and we brief every search around the mandate, not just the title. Employers can find candidates with Lecours Group or contact our team; more answers are on our FAQs page.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between retained and contingent recruitment?
Retained search is exclusive and paid in stages, with the firm committed to a full market search and assessment. Contingent recruitment is paid only on hire, usually non-exclusive, and relies mostly on candidates the firm already knows.
How long does a senior hospitality search take?
Shortlists commonly arrive within two to four weeks and placements within two to three months, but notice periods, relocation and seasonality (for example club and resort hiring cycles) can lengthen that.
Hero image: "Meeting room, table and paper board" by Luis Argerich, via Wikimedia Commons, licensed CC BY 2.0; cropped.
Current opening: General Manager, Premium Quick Service (#10343), Waterloo ON
Lecours Group is currently recruiting a General Manager for a premium quick service concept in Waterloo, Ontario, a full-accountability leadership role running the operation, the team and the results. See the role and our other current openings. Hiring a leader yourself? Start a search with Lecours Group.
