Insights

Culinary Expertise: How Clubs, Hotels and Restaurant Groups Assess It When Hiring Culinary Leaders

A chef carefully plating a row of dishes on a stainless steel kitchen pass.

Culinary expertise is easy to claim and hard to measure. Every senior chef's résumé lists award-winning menus, strong leadership and tight cost control. Yet clubs, hotels and restaurant groups still make expensive hiring mistakes at the top of the kitchen, usually because the tasting went well and nothing else was tested. This guide explains how Canadian employers can assess culinary expertise properly when hiring a Director of Culinary or culinary director, what real expertise looks like at that level, and what the role pays.

What culinary expertise means at the leadership level

For a line cook, culinary expertise mostly means technique and speed. For the person who runs a club's or a hotel's entire food operation, it means five things working together:

  1. Palate and technique: the craft itself, consistent across à la carte, banquets, events and staff meals.
  2. Menu architecture: designing menus that fit the guests or members, the kitchen's equipment and skills, the supply chain and the season.
  3. Financial control: recipe costing, food cost targets, labour scheduling, purchasing and inventory, and the ability to explain a food P&L to a general manager or a board.
  4. Team leadership: building, training and keeping a brigade, including sous chefs who can run the kitchen without the director present.
  5. Guest and stakeholder skill: working with members, owners, event clients, the F&B team and the general manager.

A candidate who is outstanding on the first point and weak on the other four may be a great chef, but not yet a director.

Why the tasting alone is not enough

The tasting remains essential, but on its own it tests a single day with hand-picked ingredients and no budget pressure. Several US search specialists now write about evaluating chefs "beyond the tasting and résumé" for exactly this reason, and some club consultants run supervised tastings as a paid service (one publishes a fee of US$2,000 plus travel for personal supervision of testing and kitchen evaluation, source). The better approach is to treat the tasting as one part of a structured assessment.

A practical framework to assess culinary expertise

1. Write the tasting brief from the mandate

Before inviting anyone, agree what the new culinary leader must achieve: modernise the menu, rebuild banquet quality, improve food cost, restart a tired dining room, or train a young brigade. Then write the tasting brief around that. A private club refreshing member dining might ask for a three-course member menu plus one banquet dish at a set plate cost. A hotel with heavy events might weight the banquet component.

2. Add an office-day exercise

Give finalists a real (anonymised) menu, recent sales mix and supplier prices, and ask for a costed menu revision, a labour plan for a busy week and a short written rationale. Canada's own top cooking designation uses this idea: the Certified Chef de Cuisine (CCC) program run by the Canadian Culinary Institute includes a theory exam, an "office day" practical on menu design and development, and a kitchen practical on menu preparation and execution, each with a 70% pass mark (Canadian Culinary Institute).

3. Review the numbers they have actually owned

Ask candidates to walk through a budget they managed: revenue, food and labour percentages, what changed under their leadership and why. Strong leaders know these numbers without notes.

4. Take references from direct reports, not only bosses

A general manager can tell you about results. A former sous chef can tell you how the kitchen felt at 7 p.m. on a Saturday, whether people were developed or burned out, and whether standards held when the director was away.

5. Check credentials and keep them in proportion

Red Seal certification and the CCC designation signal discipline and breadth. The CCC requires a valid Red Seal, five years of documented post-Red Seal employment including at least two years in a supervisory role, and a current food handler's certificate (source). Credentials are a good signal, but track record leading a kitchen matters more.

6. Meet the people they will lead and serve

For clubs, a short session with the house or F&B committee; for hotels, with the general manager and director of food and beverage. You are testing communication and judgment as much as cooking.

What culinary leadership pays

Culinary leadership at this level is priced in the six figures. Gecko Hospitality's 2025 salary survey, based on more than 1,300 hospitality and restaurant leaders in the US and Canada (a vendor survey, figures in US dollars), reports an average of US$124,500 for the top chef role in hospitality settings such as clubs, hotels and resorts, and US$112,500 for a Culinary Director in restaurant management. In Toronto, a current posting for a senior private chef role in Rosedale lists C$110,000 to C$125,000 a year (posting). Pay for a Director of Culinary at a large club or hotel depends on revenue, outlets, banquet volume and the size of the brigade, and should be benchmarked before the search starts. Our guide to the best paying culinary jobs has more context.

Common mistakes when judging culinary expertise

  • Hiring the plate, not the leader. A brilliant tasting from a candidate who has never run a full P&L.
  • Ignoring scale. A small fine dining kitchen and a club doing weddings, golf events and member dining on the same day are different jobs.
  • Skipping the brigade. If the sous chefs leave within six months, the expertise left with them.
  • Underpricing the role. The strongest culinary leaders are employed and well paid; an offer below market shrinks the pool to people who are available, not people who are best.

Related reading

How Lecours Group helps

Lecours Group has recruited culinary and hospitality leaders since 1991, in Toronto and across Canada first and selectively in New York, Miami and Atlanta. We help clubs, hotels and restaurant groups design the assessment as well as find the candidates, including tasting briefs, office-day exercises and structured referencing. Employers can find candidates with Lecours Group or contact our team. More answers are on our FAQs page.

Frequently asked questions

How do you test a chef's culinary expertise?

Combine a tasting built around your actual needs with a costed menu and labour exercise, a review of budgets the chef has owned, and references from both bosses and former team members.

Is the CCC designation required for senior chef roles in Canada?

Rarely required, but respected. Most employers look first at a proven record of leading kitchens of similar size and complexity.

Hero image: "Gourmet Chef" by Fabrizio Magoni, via Wikimedia Commons, released under CC0; cropped.

Current opening: Director of Culinary / Executive Chef, Private Golf & Country Club, London ON

Lecours Group is recruiting a Director of Culinary / Executive Chef for a private golf and country club in London, Ontario, a senior role that sets the culinary direction for the club's dining rooms, events and member experience. If your culinary expertise covers the kitchen, the numbers and the team, see the role and our other current openings. Employers can start a culinary leadership search.