Insights

Retained vs Contingency Search for Senior Hospitality Roles in Canada

An empty boardroom with a long dark table and upholstered chairs, ready for a search committee meeting.

When a private club, hotel owner or restaurant group decides to bring in outside help for a senior hire, the first real decision is not which recruiter to call. It is how the engagement will work. Retained vs contingency search is the choice between paying a firm to run an exclusive, staged process and paying only if you hire a candidate the firm introduces. Both can fill a six-figure leadership seat. They share risk differently, they behave differently in a small market, and they suit different roles. This guide is written for owners, boards and operators in Ontario and across Canada who are hiring at the level of club general manager, director of culinary, hotel general manager or multi-unit leader.

Why the model matters more for senior hospitality roles

Canada's hospitality labour market is still the tightest in the country. In Statistics Canada's Job Vacancy and Wage Survey for August 2026, accommodation and food services had 64,400 job vacancies and a job vacancy rate of 4.7%, the highest of any sector. Most of those openings are front-line, but the shortage flows upward: the people who could step into a general manager or culinary director seat are employed, busy and rarely reading job ads.

The seats themselves are significant. A live posting for the general manager of an upscale lifestyle hotel in downtown Toronto lists a salary range of $150,000 to $170,000 a year, with the GM serving as the primary liaison with ownership. When a hire at that level goes wrong, the cost is not the fee. It is months of drift in a business that depends on one person's judgement. That is why the structure of the search deserves a deliberate decision rather than a default.

How a retained search works

In a retained search, the client formally engages one firm and commits to its fee whether or not a hire is ultimately made. As JWB Hospitality, a US firm, explains in its comparison of the two models, payment is generally made in stages over the assignment, and retained searches are generally conducted on an exclusive basis. The firm is paid for the process: market research, a target list of companies, confidential direct approaches, assessment, references and support through the offer.

What you get in return is commitment. One team owns the search, reports progress against a plan and has no reason to rush a weak shortlist. Osborne Search Partners, a Toronto firm that runs retained searches for owner-managed and mid-sized businesses across Canada, publishes a one-year, no-fault, full replacement guarantee on every executive it places. Guarantees vary widely between firms, so treat that as one example of what a retained engagement can include, not a market standard.

How a contingency search works

In a contingency search, the fee is earned only when you hire a candidate the firm introduced. There is no upfront payment, which shifts the financial risk to the recruiter. Recruit Mogul, which runs general manager searches in Canada, states that its success fee is 18% of first-year base salary, payable once the employee has started, with no retainer and a three-month replacement guarantee.

Contingency can be done well. The weakness is structural: a contingency recruiter is paid only for a hire, often carries many searches at once and may be competing with other firms on the same role. For a well-defined position with a healthy candidate pool, that pressure can produce speed. For a confidential replacement or a seat with only a handful of credible candidates in the province, it can produce a rushed shortlist and several recruiters calling the same people.

What published fee ranges say

Most published benchmarks come from US firms, so use them as a reference point rather than a Canadian price list. Hearthstone Hospitality Search, a US contingency firm, puts contingency fees at typically 20% to 30% of first-year pay and retained fees at typically 30% to 35%, paid in installments, usually thirds, whether or not you hire. It notes that these ranges come from recruiting firms' own published benchmarks and that fees are negotiable. Gecko Hospitality's 2026 US benchmark report gives an observed national range of 12% to 35% for permanent placements, with 30% to 35% for premium and executive searches such as regional or multi-unit leaders and directors of operations.

Two practical points matter more than the headline percentage:

  • What the percentage applies to. First-year base salary and total first-year compensation can be very different numbers for a GM with a meaningful bonus.
  • What happens if the hire leaves early. A three-month guarantee and a one-year guarantee are not the same product, even at the same percentage.

Which model fits which seat

There is no universal answer, but the pattern is consistent across the firms quoted above. Hearthstone, which works only on contingency, says plainly that it uses contingency for department heads and unit leaders and that for corporate C-suite or regional VP searches a retained firm is the right call. In our experience the deciding factors are:

  1. Confidentiality. If the incumbent does not yet know they are being replaced, or the club's members cannot hear about it, you want one firm controlling every approach. Our guide to confidential executive search covers how that process works.
  2. Size of the real candidate pool. A director of culinary for a private golf and country club, or a GM for a resort with an active ownership group, may have a dozen credible candidates in Ontario. That calls for mapping and direct approaches, not a database search.
  3. Governance. Boards and search committees, common at private clubs, usually need a documented process, a market report and a defensible shortlist.
  4. Volume. A restaurant group hiring several unit GMs a year may prefer contingency, or a hybrid, with one firm that learns its standards.
  5. Urgency and alternatives. If an internal successor exists, you may only need an external benchmark, not a full search.

Questions to ask before you sign

  • Who will actually run the search, and how many other searches do they carry?
  • How will you find candidates: postings and a database, or a target list and direct approaches to employed leaders?
  • Is the fee based on base salary or total compensation, and when is each part due?
  • What is the guarantee period, and what triggers it?
  • Which companies are off-limits to you because they are clients?
  • How will you report progress, and how often?

The answers tell you more than the label. As JWB puts it, the more important question is how the firm actually conducts the search. For a broader view of the options, see our overview of recruitment services for employers, our note on boutique recruitment firms, and our selection process.

Canada first, with a US lens

Most of our senior work is in Ontario and across Canada, with selective searches in New York, Miami and Atlanta. US benchmarks are useful, but the Canadian market is smaller and more connected: in a province where the senior club and hotel community knows itself well, an uncontrolled search becomes common knowledge quickly. That is one more reason to agree exclusivity and an approach plan up front, whichever model you choose.

Frequently asked questions

Is retained search always better for senior roles?

No. It is better when confidentiality, a thin candidate pool or board governance make a controlled, exclusive process worth paying for. A well-run contingency search with one trusted firm can work for a clearly defined senior seat.

Can we use several contingency recruiters at once?

You can, but for leadership roles it often backfires: candidates hear about the role from several sources, and the search stops looking confidential.

What does a private club GM or director of culinary search usually need?

Typically a search committee brief, a market map of comparable clubs and hotels, confidential approaches and structured interviews. Our guide to golf club general manager search in Ontario covers the club side in more detail.

Hero image: "Conference room table (Unsplash)" by Breather, via Wikimedia Commons, dedicated to the public domain under CC0 1.0; cropped.

Current opening: Director of Culinary, private golf and country club, London ON

Lecours Group has recruited hospitality leaders since 1991, in Toronto and across Canada first and selectively in the United States. We are currently recruiting a Director of Culinary / Executive Chef for a private golf and country club in London, Ontario, exactly the kind of senior, member-facing seat this guide is about. See the role and our other current openings on our find jobs page. Clubs, hotels and restaurant groups planning a senior hire can find candidates with Lecours Group or contact our team to talk through which search model fits. You can meet our team and read more answers on our FAQs page.