Insights

Confidential Executive Search: Replacing a Hospitality Leader Who Is Still in the Role

A long, quiet hotel corridor with a red carpet runner and closed doors.

Sometimes the seat you need to fill is still occupied. A general manager is underperforming, a director of culinary has quietly told you they will retire next year, or an owner has decided the operation needs a different kind of leader. Posting the job would alert the incumbent, unsettle the team and invite speculation among guests, members and competitors. This is where a confidential executive search, often called a replacement search, comes in. This guide explains how a confidential search works for six-figure hospitality leadership roles in Canada, what it protects, what it cannot, and how to time the change.

What makes a search confidential

In a confidential executive search, the employer's name and the vacancy are not advertised. The search partner approaches candidates directly with a "blind" brief that describes the role, scale and location in general terms. The client is revealed only when a candidate is qualified, interested and has agreed to keep the discussion private.

Canadian firms describe the same discipline. Dilys Search says confidential searches are part of standard practice, reaching candidates "with a blind mandate approach, disclosing the organization only when mutual interest is confirmed and a confidentiality agreement is in place" (Dilys Search). Talent Inc. says confidential searches, "including replacement searches where an incumbent is still in post", are conducted "without naming the client until a candidate is properly qualified and bound by confidentiality" (Talent Inc.).

When owners use a confidential replacement search

  • Performance: the incumbent is not meeting the mandate and the owner wants a successor lined up before making a change.
  • Planned departures that have not been announced: retirement, relocation or a move into an ownership or corporate role.
  • Restructuring: a new owner, management company or operating model that requires a different profile.
  • Sensitive markets: private clubs, small cities and tight culinary communities where a posted vacancy is common knowledge within days.
  • Pre-announcement openings and acquisitions, where the project itself is not yet public.

How a confidential search runs

  1. A small circle. Agree who knows: typically the owner or board chair, one senior executive and the search partner. Every extra person is a leak risk.
  2. A blind brief. A role description that gives serious candidates enough to engage (scale, segment, region, the challenge, the package range) without identifying the business.
  3. Direct, discreet approach. No job boards. Candidates are approached individually and asked about their interest before any names are exchanged.
  4. Confidentiality agreements signed before the client is disclosed, then a normal selection process: structured interviews, a practical exercise and references. Our guide to the selection process explains how this changes for a GM, director of culinary or director of operations.
  5. Off-site, off-hours interviews. Meet away from the property; do not walk finalists through the hotel, club or kitchen while the incumbent is on shift.
  6. Careful references. Reference calls should not alert the candidate's current employer before an offer is accepted.
  7. A planned announcement covering the incumbent, the team, guests or members, and the owner's stakeholders on the same day.

Timing the exit and the start

A confidential search is about sequencing. Two notice periods usually matter.

Your incumbent's. In Ontario, the Employment Standards Act sets minimum written notice of termination (or pay instead of notice) for employees continuously employed for at least three months, rising from one week for less than one year of service to eight weeks for eight years or more. Those are statutory minimums; employment contracts and common law can require considerably more for senior leaders. Get employment law advice before you plan the exit, especially for long-serving GMs and culinary leaders.

Your new hire's. Senior candidates are employed and will usually owe their current employer notice under their own contracts, and may face relocation. Build that into the plan rather than assuming a quick start.

How long does the search take? Published ranges vary. Talent Inc. says a shortlist is usually presented within four to eight weeks. JWB Hospitality, a US firm, says most GM searches take 30 to 90 days and that it "can recruit while your current GM is still in place" (JWB Hospitality, US). Madison Mayfair, a UK-based global firm, says most hotel GM searches are completed within eight to twelve weeks (Madison Mayfair).

Fee models for confidential searches

Confidential replacement work is offered under both retained and contingency models. Talent Inc. runs senior and confidential searches on a retained basis. In the US, contingency firms also advertise confidential replacement work: Hearthstone Hospitality Search lists 18% of first-year base salary with a six-month replacement guarantee (Hearthstone, US), and JWB Hospitality lists 20% of first-year base salary with a 90-day guarantee for GM searches (US). For a quiet search at six-figure leadership level, the deciding questions are how the firm protects your identity, how narrowly it approaches the market and how it handles references. Our guide to recruitment services for employers compares the models in more detail.

Risks to manage

  • Leaks. Hospitality communities are small. Keep the circle tight and the brief anonymous.
  • Losing the incumbent early. If the search becomes known, the incumbent may leave before you are ready. Have an interim plan.
  • Team instability. In kitchens and clubs especially, a leadership change can trigger departures. Plan retention conversations with key people for the day of the announcement.
  • Fairness and legal exposure. Confidentiality does not change your obligations to the current employee. Treat the exit with care and advice.

Frequently asked questions

Can a private club run a confidential search for its culinary leader?

Yes, and many do. Agree with the board or search committee how few people need to know, and interview away from the clubhouse. See our guide to private club chef recruitment and golf club general manager search in Ontario.

Will candidates take a blind brief seriously?

Strong candidates will if the brief is specific about the scale, the challenge and the package range, and if they trust the person approaching them.

Should the incumbent ever be told?

That is an owner's decision, ideally made with legal advice. In planned retirements, involving the incumbent in the handover can be the best outcome for everyone.

Hero image: "Corridor at Hotel Esplanade Stockholm" by JIP, via Wikimedia Commons, licensed CC BY-SA 4.0; cropped.

Need a confidential search? Talk to Lecours Group

Lecours Group has recruited hospitality leaders since 1991, in Toronto and across Canada first and selectively in New York, Miami and Atlanta. Owners, clubs and restaurant groups can find candidates with Lecours Group or contact our team in confidence to discuss a replacement search. Culinary leaders can view our current openings, including the Director of Culinary / Executive Chef role at a private golf and country club in London, Ontario, on our find jobs page. More answers are on our FAQs page.

Written by the LecoursGroup executive search team. Meet our recruiters.