Insights

Non-Compete Clauses for Hospitality Executives in Ontario: What Employers Can Still Use

Ontario Legislative Building at Queen's Park, Toronto.

When a hotel owner, restaurant group or private club hires a senior leader, a familiar clause often appears in the draft contract: a promise that the new general manager, culinary director or regional operator will not go to work for a competitor after they leave. In Ontario, that clause is usually no longer worth the paper. Non-compete clauses for hospitality executives are prohibited for most employees under the province's Employment Standards Act, with two narrow exceptions. This guide explains, from the employer's side, what the rule says, who it does and does not cover, and what owners can use instead to protect guests, members, recipes and teams. It is general information, not legal advice; for a specific contract, speak with an employment lawyer.

What Ontario's rule says

According to the Ontario government's guide to the Employment Standards Act on non-compete agreements, effective October 25, 2021, employers are prohibited from entering into employment contracts or other agreements with an employee that include a non-compete agreement. The guide defines a non-compete agreement as an agreement, or any part of one, that prohibits the employee from engaging in any business, work, occupation, profession, project or other activity that is in competition with the employer's business after the employment relationship ends.

Three details in the guide matter for hospitality owners:

  • Time and distance limits do not save the clause. The guide gives examples: a six-month restriction is still a non-compete, and so is a restriction limited to 100 km of the employer's workplace.
  • Timing does not matter. The ban applies to agreements made with an applicant before employment begins, during employment and after it ends.
  • Substance beats the heading. What counts is what the clause actually does, not what it is called. A clause titled "Non-Competition" that only stops the employee from soliciting customers is treated as a non-solicit.

The guide also notes that the ban does not apply to non-compete agreements entered into before October 25, 2021, although employees may have greater rights under the common law.

The two exceptions, and why most hospitality leaders fall outside them

The ESA allows non-competes in only two situations. The first is a sale or lease of a business, or part of a business, operated as a sole proprietorship or partnership, where the seller becomes an employee of the purchaser immediately after the sale and agrees not to compete with the purchaser's business.

The second is for executives. The ESA guide defines an executive as any person who holds the office of chief executive officer, president, chief administrative officer, chief operating officer, chief financial officer, chief information officer, chief legal officer, chief human resources officer, chief corporate development officer, or any other chief executive position.

That list is narrower than many owners assume. A hotel general manager, a club general manager, a director of culinary, a director of food and beverage, a director of operations or an area manager is a senior leader, but the title is not a C-suite office. Writing on post-employment restrictions for HRD Canada, Kyle Lambert, a partner at McMillan LLP in Toronto, observes that guidance on the meaning of "executive" is minimal, that the ESA has been interpreted in a manner most favourable to employees, and that there is little reason to believe "any other chief executive position" captures positions outside the C-suite. A restaurant group COO or a hotel ownership group's CFO may fall within the exception; the GM of a single hotel usually will not. Some private clubs give their general manager a COO title, which is worth discussing with counsel rather than assuming it settles the question.

Even where allowed, courts look hard at non-competes

Being inside an exception does not make a clause enforceable. Lambert describes the common law test Canadian courts apply to restrictive covenants: the restriction must protect a legitimate proprietary interest such as trade secrets, confidential information or customer goodwill; it must be reasonable in time, geography and the activities it restricts; and it must be reasonable in light of the public interest. He adds that courts have said a non-compete will not be enforced where a non-solicitation covenant would adequately protect the employer. The article also notes that the federal government proposed a ban on non-competes for federally regulated employees in its Fall 2025 Budget, with consultations ongoing. That does not cover most hospitality employers, which are provincially regulated, but it shows the direction of travel.

What hospitality employers can use instead

The Ontario guide states that the ESA does not prohibit non-solicit agreements or non-disclosure agreements, though it adds that employees may have greater rights under the common law. For most senior hospitality hires, a well-drafted package of these tools protects what matters far better than a non-compete ever did.

  • Non-solicitation of employees. The real risk when a GM or chef leaves is often that they take the sous chef, the bar manager and half the line with them. A reasonable, time-limited clause against soliciting former colleagues addresses that directly.
  • Non-solicitation of clients and accounts. For catering, events, corporate sales and foodservice distribution roles, a clause against soliciting the employer's clients and accounts for a defined period protects the book of business.
  • Confidentiality. Recipes and specifications, supplier pricing, member and guest data, financials and expansion plans can be covered by a clear non-disclosure clause and a return-of-property process at exit. Lambert also points to ensuring the return of sensitive information immediately on departure.
  • Notice and transition terms. A contractual resignation notice period appropriate to the role gives the business time to plan a handover. Our guide to hospitality executive counteroffers covers the resignation stage from the hiring side.
  • Retention design. Deferred or multi-year incentives, retention payments tied to a project such as an opening or renovation, and a clear succession plan often do more to keep a leader than any restriction. Our guide to hospitality succession planning covers the bench side.

What this means when you are hiring

The non-compete ban works in both directions. If you are recruiting a senior leader from a competitor in Ontario, their old contract is unlikely to stop them joining you unless they held a C-suite office or sold a business. That widens the pool for owners hiring a GM, culinary director or sales leader, but it does not remove other obligations. Candidates may still owe their current employer contractual notice, confidentiality and, where reasonable, non-solicitation. Ask about these early, and do not encourage a new hire to bring confidential information or recruit their old team in breach of a valid clause.

Handle the approach itself with discretion. A search for a senior leader at a competitor works best when it is confidential from the first call; our note on confidential executive search explains how that is run. When you make the offer, keep restrictive covenants short, specific and in plain language, and review them with counsel. Our guide to a senior hospitality compensation package covers the rest of the offer letter.

Canada first, with a US lens

This article covers Ontario. Rules on restrictive covenants differ by province and, in the United States, by state. If you hire across borders, including for searches in New York, Miami and Atlanta, have each contract reviewed under the law that governs it.

Frequently asked questions

Can we make our hotel GM sign a six-month non-compete?

In Ontario, generally no. Unless the GM holds a C-suite office or the sale-of-business exception applies, a non-compete entered into on or after October 25, 2021 is prohibited, whatever its length.

Are non-solicitation clauses still allowed?

Yes. The ESA does not prohibit non-solicit or non-disclosure agreements, but they must still be reasonable to be enforceable at common law.

What if an old contract has a non-compete?

Agreements made before October 25, 2021 are not caught by the ESA ban, but enforceability at common law is a separate question for a lawyer.

Hero image: "Ontario Legislative Building, Toronto" by Maksim Sokolov (Maxergon), via Wikimedia Commons, licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0; cropped.

Current opening: Outside Sales Representative, Markham ON

Lecours Group has recruited hospitality and food industry leaders since 1991, in Toronto and across Canada first and selectively in the United States. We are currently recruiting an Outside Sales Representative in Markham, Ontario (#10875), a client-facing role where clear confidentiality and non-solicitation terms matter to both employer and candidate. See the role and our other current openings on our find jobs page, and read our guide to foodservice sales recruitment. Employers planning a senior hire can find candidates with Lecours Group or contact our team. You can meet our team and read more answers on our FAQs page.