Most hospitality businesses discover their succession plan on the day a key leader resigns. The general manager accepts an offer elsewhere, the head of the kitchen announces a move, and the owner learns there is no one ready. Hospitality succession planning is the discipline of making sure that day is an inconvenience rather than a crisis. This guide looks at succession for the seats that matter most in Canadian hotels, restaurant groups and private clubs, with a focus on general managers and culinary leaders, and explains how an outside search partner helps you benchmark internal successors against the market.
What succession planning is, and what it is not
A replacement list names a backup for a role. A succession plan goes further: it identifies who could step in now, who could be ready in one to two years, what each person needs to get there, and what you are doing about it. Cornerstone Hospitality puts it simply: a replacement plan answers "who could we put in the seat?", while a succession plan answers "who will be ready for the seat, and what are we doing about it?" (Cornerstone Hospitality).
Why it matters: what the research says
There is little Canadian hospitality-specific research on succession, so it is worth being clear about what the broader evidence shows and where it comes from.
- The bench is thinner than organisations think. Leadership consultancy DDI reports that 75% of organisations prioritise internal promotion over external hiring, yet internal candidates can fill only 49% of critical positions immediately (DDI, global research across industries).
- External hires cost more and take time to settle. Wharton professor Matthew Bidwell found that external hires were paid about 18% to 20% more than internal staff promoted into similar jobs, received lower performance evaluations for their first two years and had higher exit rates (Knowledge at Wharton; the study used US investment banking data, not hospitality).
Neither finding means you should never hire externally. They mean that a business with no ready successors pays a premium every time a key leader leaves, and has fewer options when it does.
The seats to plan for first
Do not try to plan succession for every role. Start with the seats where a vacancy would hurt results within a quarter:
- General manager of each hotel, club or flagship restaurant.
- Head of culinary: director of culinary or head chef, plus the chef de cuisine of your most important outlet.
- Director of operations or hotel manager, often the GM's natural successor. See hotel director of operations recruitment.
- Director of food and beverage in hotels and clubs where F&B drives a large share of revenue.
- Finance and sales leaders in groups where owner reporting and group business depend on one person.
General manager succession
GM succession usually runs through the director of operations, hotel manager, director of food and beverage or director of rooms, or through a GM at a smaller sister property. For each candidate, write down what would have to be true for them to be ready: owner-facing experience, full P&L accountability, a turnaround or pre-opening, or leading departments outside their specialism. Then create those experiences on purpose: acting GM cover, task-force assignments, ownership meetings. Warren Averett, a US accounting and advisory firm, suggests that when a retirement is known in advance, overlap between the current leader and the successor can reduce disruption and preserve institutional knowledge (Warren Averett, US). Our guide to hotel general manager recruitment covers the external search when no internal successor is ready. When the seat cannot sit empty in the meantime, our guide to interim hospitality management covers how Canadian owners fill the gap.
Culinary succession
Kitchens are personal. The head of a kitchen carries recipes, supplier relationships, the brigade's loyalty and, in clubs, the members' trust. That makes culinary succession both more important and more fragile. Practical steps:
- Develop a clear number two. A chef de cuisine or senior sous chef who runs service, costs menus and leads the brigade without the head of culinary in the room. Our chef de cuisine job description shows the scope.
- Document the kitchen. Recipes, specifications, supplier terms, costing tools and event templates should belong to the business, not one person.
- Expose successors to the business side: budgets, labour scheduling, member or owner meetings, menu presentations.
- Test readiness honestly, for example with a tasting and costing exercise reviewed by someone outside the kitchen.
Training and career growth for cooks are covered in our separate article on chef development; this article is about the leadership seats. For clubs, see private club chef recruitment.
Internal versus external: benchmark both
The hardest succession question is whether your internal candidate is genuinely the best option. A search firm can help in three ways:
- Market benchmarking. Quietly compare your internal successor's experience and results with external leaders in comparable roles in Toronto, Ontario and across Canada.
- Development gaps. Use that comparison to show the successor what they need to build, with a timeline.
- A warm external pipeline. Keep relationships with a small number of external leaders so a vacancy does not start from zero. If a change has to stay quiet, a confidential executive search can run alongside the internal plan.
Making the plan work
- Review it quarterly, not annually, and change it when people move.
- Name successors at more than one level, so one departure does not empty the bench.
- Reward leaders for developing successors. A GM who exports talent to other properties should be recognised, not penalised.
- Talk to successors. People who do not know they are in the plan are easier to lose.
- Pay attention to retention of the successors themselves; a development plan without a path to the role invites them to leave.
Frequently asked questions
How many successors should each key role have?
Ideally one "ready now" and one "ready in one to two years". For small groups, one credible successor plus a known external option is a realistic start.
Is succession planning only for large hotel groups?
No. Independent restaurants and single clubs often need it most, because one departure can affect the whole operation.
Hero image: "In the kitchen" by Anthony O'Neil, via Wikimedia Commons, licensed CC BY-SA 2.0; cropped.
Building your bench? Work with Lecours Group
Lecours Group has recruited hospitality leaders since 1991, in Toronto and across Canada first and selectively in New York, Miami and Atlanta. Employers can find candidates with Lecours Group or contact our team to benchmark internal successors or plan a leadership search. Culinary leaders preparing for the next step can view our current openings, including a Chef de Cuisine (#10877) role at a private club in Toronto, Ontario, on our find jobs page. More answers are on our FAQs page.
Written by the LecoursGroup executive search team. Meet our recruiters.
