A club can admire its general manager all year and still be unprepared when the board changes, a director has a complaint or the annual review is finally put on the calendar. Club general manager performance evaluation is how a Canadian board turns impressions into a documented conversation: what was agreed, what was delivered, what should continue and whether the relationship still works. Done well, the review supports retention and an honest look at leadership continuity. Done poorly, or not at all, it is often the moment a board discovers it is already late to start a search.
This guide is written for club presidents, boards and general managers at Canadian private clubs, especially in Ontario. It is not a job-seeker tip sheet. Lecours Group's hospitality recruiters see a clear pattern: clubs that review their general manager against written goals make better keep-or-search decisions than clubs that rely on corridor opinion.
Where this page fits
This page is about the annual review of a sitting club general manager. It is not a plan for leadership continuity, and it is not a brief for hiring the deputy to the general manager. Those subjects are covered in our hospitality succession planning guide and our private club assistant general manager recruitment page. Keep those neighbouring guides linked but distinct, so this brief stays on how the board evaluates the person already in the chair.
Why informal reviews fail clubs
Kopplin Kuebler & Wallace have made this point directly to the club market. In their guide to a modern performance-management system, they report that they are often surprised, when placing executives or speaking with strong general managers, to find a subjective review process or no process at all, and they see a connection between managers who are not receiving feedback and managers who are later let go. They argue that the absence of a measurable system creates blind spots, and that board turnover makes an informal process even less reliable, because each new president can arrive with a different definition of success.
That matches what we see in Canadian clubs. A general manager can have a productive year and still be exposed if the only record of that year is a handful of comments from the directors who spoke most often. The next board is then free to rewrite the story. A formal review does not prevent disagreement. It makes the disagreement specific.
What a usable annual review contains
The review should start with goals that were agreed at the beginning of the year, not with a blank page in December. KK&W recommend that the general manager and the president or executive committee set those goals together, then meet mid-year and again at year-end, and that the criteria be agreed in a small, informed group rather than invented in a full board argument. The areas they treat as common ground are useful in a Canadian club as well, provided they are turned into evidence rather than slogans: member satisfaction, employee satisfaction, financial management, membership health, people leadership, capital and building stewardship, strategic leadership and communications.
We do not publish bonus formulae or pay figures in this guide, and we do not repeat KK&W's incentive examples. The review should stand even if any performance arrangement is discussed separately. Score what the general manager can actually influence, write down the evidence, and keep the conversation inside the group that has the authority to have it.
CMAA has made a related governance point in its March/April 2023 BoardBrief, in a section excerpted from CMAA's Director's Guide for Understanding Club Governance. The piece treats the executive session as a proper place for the board to discuss the general manager's or chief operating officer's performance as part of its duty to evaluate, and it is direct about the risk: when those sessions become a standing habit without discipline, they can turn into a venue for second-hand complaints about operating issues or staff. CMAA's guidance is that personal experiences and rumours should go to the general manager for response, that the evaluation should be based on clear and measurable goals, and that the general manager should also be assessed on how they manage the organization and handle problems. It is the president's responsibility to share executive-session concerns with the general manager so they can be acted on. The best clubs, the Brief says, treat the board and the general manager as being in it together.
Write the method down, then keep it when the board changes
A review that lives only in the president's memory will not survive a change of officers. Global Golf Advisors' 2016 Guide to Implementing the Club Governance Model, which CMAA designated as its standard of excellence in governance, treats policies that specify how the board will evaluate the general manager as a core practice, and it places those practices in a Board Policies Manual so they are documented and applied consistently. In that model, the general manager is the board's single operational agent, working within the boundaries the board has set. The evaluation then has a clear subject: did the general manager carry out the club's purpose within those boundaries, and did the board stay on its own side of the line?
Canadian clubs do not need to adopt every element of that model to benefit from the idea. They do need a written method that a new president can pick up: who participates, when the mid-year and year-end conversations happen, which goals are in play, and how the outcome is recorded. The general manager should help design that method. A review invented only by the board, and revealed only at the end of the year, is an ambush, not an evaluation.
How the review connects to keeping a leader, or starting a search
A serious review has three possible outcomes, and the board should be willing to name them. The first is that the general manager is succeeding and the mandate should be renewed or sharpened. That is a retention conversation: confirm the work, confirm the support the board will provide, and do not assume the leader will infer all of that from a pleasant dinner. The second is that there are specific gaps, and a written plan and a mid-year check are enough to close them. The third is that the gaps are structural, or trust has gone, and the club needs a planned transition.
The third outcome is where clubs lose time. They postpone the decision, hope the next president will feel differently, and then find themselves starting a search under pressure. Our hospitality succession planning guide is the place to work out how a club prepares for a leadership change before it is urgent. If the review also exposes a missing deputy or a thin leadership bench, our private club assistant general manager recruitment page is the place to think about that seat. This page's job is to make sure the review itself is good enough to support those later decisions.
The review is also a chance to check whether the GM has the team they need. Gaps often show up in finance, events or racquets; see our guides to hiring a private club director of finance, hiring a social events manager and hiring a director of racquets.
The same review discipline should reach the GM's direct reports. A GM is only as strong as the department heads around them, and boards often learn too late that the problem sat in facilities or wellness rather than in the GM's office. When a review shows that a key seat needs a new leader, our guides to hiring a private club director of facilities and hiring a private club fitness director explain what to look for.
Common mistakes boards make
- Having no written goals, then calling the year-end conversation a review.
- Letting executive session become a complaint hour about food, parking or a single member's experience.
- Changing the criteria every time the officers change.
- Discussing only financial results, or only personality, as if either one were the whole job.
- Avoiding a clear keep-or-transition decision once the evidence is already in.
A strong general manager will not be damaged by a fair review. They will be damaged by a year of silence followed by a surprise. Put the dates on the calendar now.
What a hospitality-rooted firm adds
Lecours Group helps club boards turn a vague sense of how the year went into a documented club general manager performance evaluation, and into a clear decision about what comes next. Review the hospitality clients we've placed for when considering organisations that trust us with senior club appointments.
Start a confidential conversation
If you want help designing a club general manager performance evaluation, or you already know the next step is a search, tell us about the mandate through our find candidates page. If you are exploring leadership opportunities, we are currently recruiting a Director of Culinary / Executive Chef for a private golf and country club in London, Ontario. Review that search and our other current openings. That culinary mandate is a live example of a senior club search, not a general-manager vacancy. This page is not itself a vacancy advertisement.
Our team has spent years advising Canadian clubs on senior leadership. Meet our recruiters and see who would support your process.
Photo: “The Toronto Club, 107-109 Wellington Street West in Toronto” by Oaktree b, via Wikimedia Commons, licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0; unchanged. Illustrative Toronto private club setting only; no endorsement or client relationship implied.
